Is the January Effect Real? 100 Years of Small vs Big Stocks, Tested
It was the strongest calendar pattern in the stock market. Then it was published.
By Pavel Penev, MScFounder, TradeWize · 10+ years trading the marketsThe short answer
It was real, and it's mostly gone. The S&P 500 isn't special in January: it rose in 62 of 99 of them, about as often as any month. The real January effect is small stocks beating big ones. The smallest tenth of US stocks beat the biggest tenth in 78 of 100 Januaries since 1927, by +6.1 points on average. Before 1976, when it was published, that happened 43 times in 49. Since 2010 it's 8 of 17, and the gain now tends to arrive in late December instead.
Every December, someone tells you to buy before the January effect.
Most of the time they mean stocks go up in January. That isn't what the research found. In 1976 two economists, Michael Rozeff and William Kinney, showed that January returns were unusually high. In 1983 Donald Keim showed where most of it came from: small companies.
So we tested both versions. For the index, we used 99 Januaries of the S&P 500. For small against big, we used 100 Januaries of Ken French's size portfolios, which cover every US-listed stock back to 1926. Then we checked whether luck could produce a month that good, and what happened after the secret got out.
Finding 1: the S&P 500 isn't special in January
The S&P 500 rose in 62 of 99 Januaries from 1928 to 2026. That's 63% of the time. Across every month in that span, 60% rose.
The average January gained +1.21%. That's good, but it's only the fourth best month. July averaged +1.67%. By how often it rose, January comes third. December rose most often, in 71 of 98 years.
| Month | Years up | Average | Median |
|---|---|---|---|
| January | 62 of 99 | +1.21% | +1.55% |
| February | 51 of 99 | −0.11% | +0.20% |
| March | 60 of 99 | +0.42% | +1.00% |
| April | 65 of 99 | +1.36% | +0.94% |
| May | 60 of 99 | +0.13% | +1.07% |
| June | 56 of 99 | +0.79% | +0.30% |
| July | 60 of 99 | +1.67% | +1.62% |
| August | 58 of 99 | +0.70% | +0.88% |
| September | 44 of 99 | −1.11% | −0.45% |
| October | 58 of 99 | +0.53% | +0.93% |
| November | 61 of 98 | +1.01% | +1.63% |
| December | 71 of 98 | +1.27% | +1.48% |
S&P 500 closes, price only, 1928 to October 2026. Each month runs from the last close of the month before to its own last close.
So if someone tells you the market goes up in January, they're right, about as often as it goes up in any other month.
Finding 2: small stocks were special
Now split the market by size. Ken French sorts every US stock by its market value each June. The smallest tenth are tiny companies, worth about $161 million each on average in 2026. The biggest tenth are giants, worth about $293 billion each.
In January, the small tenth beat the big tenth in 78 of 100 years. The average gap was +6.1 points, and the median +4.7 points. That's a huge gap for one month.
How often the smallest tenth of US stocks beat the biggest tenth in each calendar month, 1926-2026. January is the green bar.
No other month comes close. The next best is February, at 54 of 100. In most months small stocks lost to big ones slightly more often than they won.
We also checked whether luck could do this. We dealt every month's gap from 1927 to 2025 at random into 12 fake months, 20,000 times. The best fake month never matched January. The highest it ever reached was +4.3 points, against January's +6.1 points. Over the whole century, this was no accident.
Finding 3: it faded after it was published
Split the record at 1976, when Rozeff and Kinney published. From 1927 to 1975, small beat big in 43 of 49 Januaries, by +9.1 points on average. From 1976 to 1999 it was 19 of 24, by +3.8 points. From 2000 to 2026 it was 16 of 27, by +2.5 points.
The smallest tenth's January return minus the biggest tenth's, averaged by decade. The dashed line marks 1976, when the effect was first published.
Since 2010 it's 8 of 17, with a median of −0.3 points. The average is still +0.9 points, but one year carries it: January 2021, the month of the meme-stock squeeze, at +17.8 points. Leave it out and the average is −0.1 points.
The luck test changes too. Run on 2000 to 2025 alone, the best of 12 fake months matches January 11% of the time. That's no longer a pattern you can tell apart from noise.
| Years | Small won | Average gap | Median gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1927-1975 | 43 of 49 | +9.1 points | +7.2 points |
| 1976-1999 | 19 of 24 | +3.8 points | +3.1 points |
| 2000-2026 | 16 of 27 | +2.5 points | +2.4 points |
| 2010-2026 | 8 of 17 | +0.9 points | −0.3 points |
| All, 1927-2026 | 78 of 100 | +6.1 points | +4.7 points |
Ken French size portfolios: the smallest tenth of US stocks minus the biggest tenth, value-weighted, dividends in.
This is what usually happens to a pattern once it's in the textbooks. Traders buy earlier to get ahead of it, and the gain spreads out or disappears.
Finding 4: the fund version never had it
Most people who try to trade the January effect buy a small-cap fund, usually one that tracks the Russell 2000. Those aren't the tiny stocks in the research. The Russell 2000 holds mid-sized and smaller companies, and the very smallest stocks aren't in it at all.
The Russell 2000 beat the S&P 500 in only 16 of 39 Januaries from 1988 to 2026. The median gap was −0.12 points. In every other month it won 214 of 429 times, about half. From 1988 to 1999, it won only 3 of 12 Januaries. Since 2000 it's 13 of 27.
So the version you can actually buy in one ticket didn't have a January effect in the years we can measure it.
Learn it by doing
Reading about it is one thing — it clicks when you do it. Learn it hands-on with free, interactive lessons on TradeWize.
Try the free lesson →Finding 5: what's left of it moved into December
The usual explanation is tax-loss selling. Investors sell losing stocks in December to claim the loss on that year's taxes. Small, beaten-down stocks get hit hardest. In January the selling stops and they bounce back.
If traders know the bounce is coming, they buy before it starts. So we used daily data and split the turn of the year into four windows.
The smallest tenth of US stocks minus the biggest tenth in four windows around New Year, averaged over 1927-1975 and 2000-2026.
Before 1976, small stocks lost to big ones in the second half of December most years. They won in only 16 of 49 years, with an average gap of −1.02 points. Then the first five trading days of January did the work. Small won 48 of 49 times, by +4.81 points on average.
Since 2000 it's turned around. Small stocks won the second half of December in 22 of 27 years, by +1.47 points on average. The first five days of January dropped to 16 of 27, and the rest of the month to 17 of 27. Since 2010, late December still went to small stocks 14 times in 17.
Gains of a point or so over two weeks are small. They're also on the smallest, least traded stocks, where the spread between buying and selling can eat most of it.
Finding 6: the January barometer
There's a second January claim: "as January goes, so goes the year." We tested it on the S&P 500, 1928-2025. For each year we compared January with the rest of the year, from January's close to December's.
After an up January, the rest of the year rose 48 times in 61, with a median of +11.8%. After a down January, it rose 22 times in 37, with a median of +2.5%. So there's a lean.
But it's a weak tool. The barometer called the rest of the year right 63 times in 98. Guessing "up" every single year was right 70 times. And even after a down January, the market still rose most years.
It also gets picked from a crowd. A gap this big turns up by chance in 3.7% of shuffles. January does make the best barometer of the 12 months. The rest of the year rose 19 points more often after an up January than after a down one. But with 12 months to choose from, one of them was always going to look good.
What people say
Buy stocks before January. They go up.
- The S&P 500 always does well in January.
- Small-cap funds jump in January.
- A down January means a down year.
What the data says
Tiny stocks used to win January. Now it's late December, if anything.
- The S&P 500 rose in 62 of 99 Januaries, about average.
- The Russell 2000 beat the S&P in 16 of 39.
- After a down January, the rest of the year rose 22 of 37 times.
What it was worth in dollars
Say you held the biggest tenth of stocks all year, but switched into the smallest tenth for every January. From 1927 to 1975, $100 would have become about $252,075. Holding the big tenth the whole time made about $4,485.
| Years | Switch to small stocks each January | Hold big stocks all year |
|---|---|---|
| 1927-1975 | $252,075 | $4,485 |
| 2000-2025 | $1,298 | $712 |
| 2010-2025 | $995 | $900 |
| 1988-2025, Russell 2000 in January vs S&P 500 | $2,652 | $2,771 |
The first three rows use Ken French size portfolios with dividends. The last row uses index prices only. No fees, spreads or taxes.
That first row is the most famous result in calendar investing, and almost nobody could have earned it. The tiniest stocks of the 1930s traded rarely, with wide spreads. Since 2010 the switch made $995 against $900, before any costs. With the Russell 2000 in place of the tiny stocks, it lost: $2,652 against $2,771.
How to read it
- When someone says "the January effect," ask which one. The index version never really existed. The small-stock version did.
- Don't buy a small-cap fund for January. The Russell 2000 beat the S&P 500 in 16 of 39 Januaries.
- If you want to trade what's left, it's in the second half of December, in the smallest stocks, and it's a point or two before costs.
- Don't sell because January was down. The rest of the year still rose 22 of 37 times.
- It can still show up. In January 2026 the small tenth beat the big tenth by +3.5 points. One good year isn't a comeback, though.
What is the January effect?
It's the pattern of small stocks beating big ones in January. The smallest tenth of US stocks beat the biggest tenth in 78 of 100 Januaries from 1927 to 2026, by +6.1 points on average.
Is the January effect still real?
Mostly not. Small stocks beat big ones in 43 of 49 Januaries before 1976, and 8 of 17 since 2010. What's left tends to show up in the second half of December instead.
Do stocks go up in January?
Usually, but no more than in other months. The S&P 500 rose in 62 of 99 Januaries since 1928, with an average gain of +1.21%. December rose more often.
What causes the January effect?
The usual explanations are tax-loss selling in December, which pushes down small losing stocks, and fund managers selling embarrassing holdings before year-end reports. Both pressures lift in January. The data shows the pattern, not which cause is right.
Does the January barometer work?
Weakly. After an up January the S&P 500 rose over the rest of the year 48 of 61 times, and after a down one 22 of 37 times. But guessing "up" every year beat the barometer, 70 correct calls to 63.
Method, and what this cannot tell you
We used two sets of data. For small against big stocks, we took Ken French's size portfolios, built from the CRSP database of every US-listed stock: the smallest tenth by market value and the biggest tenth, with dividends included, monthly from 1926 to September 2026 and daily over the same span. For the index, we took S&P 500 and Russell 2000 closes from Yahoo Finance, price only, through October 2026. Each month runs from the last close of the month before to its own last close. To test luck, we dealt every month's small-minus-big gap at random into 12 fake months, 20,000 times, and counted how often the best fake month beat the real January.
- The smallest tenth of US stocks is really tiny: micro-caps worth about $160 million on average in 2026. Many trade thinly, with wide spreads, so the paper returns overstate what a buyer could have kept.
- The French portfolios include dividends and the index figures don't. That doesn't change the January comparison, since both sides of each gap are measured the same way.
- A hundred Januaries is a decent sample, but the eras are short. Since 2010 there are only 17 of them, so one or two big years can swing the result.
- We split the history around when the effect was published (1976 and 1983). That's a choice made after looking, and a different split would move the numbers.
- None of this says why the effect happened. Tax-loss selling in December and fund managers tidying their books are the usual explanations, and the data here can't tell them apart.
Learn to test a pattern before you trade it
Our technical analysis track teaches you to read charts and check a pattern against the data, with charts you practise on.