Should You Buy a Stock at Its 52-Week High? 10,754 Highs, Tested
Some traders only buy stocks making new highs. Others won't touch one until it pulls back. We tested every month-end close of today's S&P 500 stocks since 1991 to see who's right.
By Pavel Penev, MScFounder, TradeWize · 10+ years trading the marketsEvery quote page shows a stock's 52-week high. When the price hits it, traders split into two camps.
One camp buys. A new high means buyers are in charge, and strong stocks tend to stay strong. The other camp waits. The stock looks expensive, and buying at the top of the range feels like buying the top.
We tested both. We took every month-end close of the stocks in today's S&P 500 from January 1991 to October 2025, and checked what happened next. 10,754 of those closes were a new 52-week high.
The short answer
Buying at a 52-week high isn't buying the top. A year later those stocks were higher 72% of the time, about the same as any stock (71%). But it isn't an edge either. They beat the typical S&P 500 stock 49.0% of the time. The high tells you about the past year, not the next one.
What this article is, and isn't
This is a test with public data, not personal financial advice, and there are no affiliate links on this page. Every source is linked at the end.
What a 52-week high is
A stock's 52-week high is the highest price it has reached in the past year. When it closes above that price, it has made a new 52-week high.
It happens more than you'd think. In a typical month, about 5% of S&P 500 stocks end the month at a new 52-week high. In a strong month it can be nearly a third.
The idea of buying new highs has been around for a long time. Momentum traders and breakout traders build whole strategies on it. Value investors tend to do the opposite and look for stocks that have fallen a long way.
How we tested it
We started with the 503 stocks in the S&P 500 today and their daily prices since 1990, with dividends counted. On the last trading day of every month, we checked how far each stock closed below its highest close of the past 52 weeks.
Then we measured each stock over the next one, three, six and 12 months. We compared it with the S&P 500, and with the median of all the other S&P 500 stocks over the same dates. We call that one the typical stock.
That's 163,351 stock-months in all. We used closing prices, so the high here is the highest close, not the highest price during a day.
Buying at a high isn't buying the top
This is the fear that stops most people. You buy at the high, and the stock falls straight back.
It didn't happen more often than usual. A stock bought at a new 52-week high was higher a year later 71.6% of the time. A stock bought at any month-end was higher 70.7% of the time.
What about a quick drop first? Stocks bought at a high fell 10% or more below the price paid at some point in the next year 49% of the time. For any stock it was 52%. So a new high didn't make a painful dip more likely.
Today's S&P 500 stocks, bought at a month-end close. The 10% drop is measured on closing prices within the next 12 months.
A stock doesn't know where its high is. The price people paid last year doesn't hold it back.
But it isn't an edge either
Now the other camp. Do stocks at a new high beat the rest? Over the next year they beat the typical S&P 500 stock 49.0% of the time. The median gap was −0.5%.
It's the same at shorter lengths: 47.0% after one month, 48.2% after three, 48.5% after six. Against the S&P 500 itself they won 52.0% of the time over a year. All of it is close to a coin flip.
It also swings a lot from year to year. Buying new highs beat the typical stock in 14 of 35 years. Its best year was 2001 (67%). Its worst was 2016 (34%).
Stocks at a new 52-week high at each month-end, grouped by the year they were bought. Green years beat the typical S&P 500 stock more than half the time.
The bad years tend to come when the market turns. The stocks at highs are often the safe ones that held up in a sell-off, and they lag when the beaten-down stocks bounce back.
2020 is the clearest case. From April to July, right after the crash, 110 stocks closed a month at a new high. Only 30 of them (27%) beat the typical stock over the next year.
| Decade | Buys at a new high | Beat the typical S&P 500 stock, next 12 months |
|---|---|---|
| 1990s | 2,487 | 50.0% |
| 2000s | 2,261 | 49.0% |
| 2010s | 4,012 | 47.8% |
| 2020s | 1,994 | 50.1% |
Today's S&P 500 stocks, month-end closes. The 2020s run to October 2025, the last month with a full year after it.
Learn it by doing
Reading about it is one thing — it clicks when you do it. Learn it hands-on with free, interactive lessons on TradeWize.
Try the free lesson →The trap: beaten-down stocks look like bargains
Here's where the test gets interesting. Sort the stocks by how far they sat below their high, and the further down they were, the better they did. Stocks 50% or more below their high beat the typical stock 63.7% of the time over the next year.
Share of stock-months that beat the typical S&P 500 stock over the next year. The grey bars are the ones survivorship bias inflates most.
That looks like a great strategy: buy the stocks that have been crushed. It isn't, and the reason is who's on the list.
Every stock in this test is in the S&P 500 today. A stock that fell 50% and kept falling went bust, got bought cheaply or dropped out of the index. It isn't here. The only crushed stocks on the list are the ones that came back. That's survivorship bias.
Stocks at a new high don't have that problem, or not nearly as much. So the bias makes beaten-down stocks look better, and makes stocks at a high look worse by comparison.
A test without the survivors problem
To check, we ran the same test on funds that are all still trading: the 9 sector funds that split up the S&P 500 (tested from 1999), and 19 country funds (from 1997). Nothing dropped out, so there's no bias to hide.
| Group | At a new 52-week high | 20% or more below it |
|---|---|---|
| Sector funds | beat the others 51.9% of the time | beat the others 53.0% of the time |
| Country funds | beat the others 54.2% of the time | beat the others 53.8% of the time |
Over the next 12 months, against the median of the other funds in the same group on the same dates. Sector SPDR and iShares country funds, Yahoo Finance prices with dividends.
The crushed-stock edge disappears. Funds far below their high won about as often as funds at a new high, and both were close to 50%. Neither one was a strategy.
What the research says
Researchers have found a 52-week-high effect, but in a different market. In 1993, Jegadeesh and Titman showed that US stocks that had risen most over the past few months kept beating the rest for the next three to 12 months. That's momentum.
In 2004, George and Hwang found that how close a stock sat to its 52-week high predicted its returns better than its past return did. Their test covered every US stock, small companies included, from 1963 to 2001.
Our test is narrower. It's today's biggest companies, after 1990, and the survivors problem tilts it against stocks at a high. On that list we can't see an edge. In 2016, Daniel and Moskowitz also showed that momentum can crash hard when the market rebounds after a fall. That fits what we saw in 2020.
What it means if a stock you like is at a new high
Don't skip it because it's at a high. In our test, stocks at a high were no more likely to fall over the next year than any other stock.
Don't buy it just because it's at a high either. On the S&P 500's big stocks, a new high was a coin flip against the typical stock.
And be careful with stocks that have crashed. They look cheap, and the ones you hear about later are the ones that came back. The ones that didn't come back aren't in anyone's chart.
What this test can't tell you
- It only covers stocks in the S&P 500 today. Companies that failed, were bought or left the index aren't here. That's why we compared each stock with other survivors, and checked the result on funds.
- We checked once a month, at the close. A stock that hit a new high mid-month and fell back by month-end doesn't count as at a high.
- The high is the highest close of the past 52 weeks. Most quote pages use the highest intraday price, which is a little higher.
- Prices come from Yahoo Finance, adjusted for splits and dividends, up to November 2026. There are no trading costs or taxes.
- It's big US stocks only. Small stocks and other markets can behave differently, and that's where most of the published momentum research comes from.
So should you buy a stock at its 52-week high?
If you like the company, the high isn't a reason to wait. A year later, stocks bought at a new high were up 72% of the time, the same as any stock.
But the high isn't a reason to buy either. Against the typical S&P 500 stock, it won 49.0% of the time. Decide on the company, not on where the price sits in its range.
Is it bad to buy a stock at its 52-week high?
Not in our test. Of 10,754 times a stock in today's S&P 500 closed a month at a new 52-week high since 1991, it was higher a year later 72% of the time. Stocks bought at any month-end were higher 71% of the time.
Do stocks keep going up after a 52-week high?
About as often as other stocks. Stocks at a new high beat the typical S&P 500 stock 49.0% of the time over the next 12 months, and the S&P 500 52.0% of the time.
Is it better to buy stocks near their 52-week low?
It looks that way in a list of today's stocks, but that's survivorship bias: the crushed stocks that kept falling aren't on the list. Funds that can't drop out show no edge for buying far below the high.
How often do stocks hit a 52-week high?
In a typical month, about 5% of S&P 500 stocks close at a new 52-week high. In a strong month it can be nearly a third, and in a crash almost none.
What is the 52-week high effect?
It's a finding from a 2004 study by George and Hwang: across all US stocks from 1963 to 2001, stocks close to their 52-week high went on to beat stocks far from it. We didn't find that edge in today's big S&P 500 stocks since 1991.
Learn to read a chart before you buy
Our lessons cover trends, breakouts and support and resistance, with real chart exercises in every lesson.